Best New England Style Lobster Roll

Lobster roll with pinwheel and flower
  • Save
  • Save
New England Style Lobster Roll

When most people think of Cape Cod, they think of quaint little villages by the sea with streets lined with Artisan shops filled with every souvenir imaginable.  But when I think of Cape Cod, I think about my family and lobster rolls.

Every summer as a child and into adulthood, my family packs up and drives to Cape Cod to spend the Fourth of July week playing mini golf, swimming and just enjoying the salt air.  At least once during that week,  we head to the Raw Bar at the Popponesset Marketplace.   It is located in Mashpee and they are famous for their lobster rolls. Even today, it is still one of my favorite things to do.

The Rolls

I like to use  New England hot dog buns for my lobster rolls, as this is the traditional one used here in the northeast.   These rolls are slit on top and the lobster salad sits in the center.   You can grill them up with a little butter for a fantastic crisp toasted bun.  Any hot dog bun will do, but I do feel sorry for the folks who can’t get these in their regular supermarket, as I know they are not readily available outside of New England.

This recipe is simple to make and an absolute summer favorite.

Ingredients

  1. 2 cups lobster meat  
  2. ½ tsp Kosher salt 
  3. ¼ tsp black pepper 
  4. 1 tsp lemon juice 
  5. ⅓ cup mayonnaise 
  6. 3 dashes tabasco sauce 
  7. 1 tbsp finely chopped green onion 
  8. ¼ cup Chopped celery
  9.  hot dog rolls 
  10. 2 tbsp butter 

Making the Lobster Salad

Place lobster meat in bowl
  • Save
  • place lobster meat in bowl and add salt, pepper, lemon juice, mayo, tabasco, green onion, and celery
Place all other ingredients into the bowl with lobster.
  • Save
  • place all other ingredients into the bowl with lobster except for the hot dogs
Mix together gently, cover with plastic wrap and refrigerate for minimum 30 minutes.
  • Save
  • mix together gently, cover with plastic wrap and refrigerate for minimum 30 minutes.
Butter both sides of hot dog rolls and place on a skillet on medium heat.
  • Save
  • Butter both sides of hot dog rolls and place on a skillet on medium heat.
Grill both sides of bread until golden brown.
  • Save
  • Grill both sides of bread until golden brown.
Lobster roll with pinwheel and flower
  • Save
  • Save
  • Remove lobster salad mix from the refrigerator and place onto the grilled hot dog bun. 

Enjoy!!

If this isn’t the seafood dish you were looking for, try one of these scrumptious recipes!

Check out our recommended products page, for top rated gadgets!

  • Save
Leave a comment

I love to hear from my readers. If you liked a recipe that you found here, please let me know.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.