Key lime
  • Save
Key Lime Pie with a Twist

Key Lime Pie

Twist of lime as a garnish? Yes, but the twist you see, is my special ingredient  “Greek yogurt”.  When thinking of summer desserts, Key Lime Pie always to come to mind. This pie was named after the key limes that are native to the Florida Keys. Citrus fruits give food a fresh summer flavor. Biting into this fresh key lime pie takes your senses on a trip to the Florida Keys.

Recipes that incorporate extra protein are very prevalent these days.  One way to add protein to a dessert is by adding Greek yogurt.  My key lime yogurt pie has a fresh, light and limey taste that isn’t too sweet. I substituted the traditional sweetened condensed milk for yogurt in this recipe and topped it off with some fresh whipped cream.

The crust of choice this time is the standard graham cracker crust.  It’s the perfect summertime dessert!


Graham Cracker Crust

  1. 9 graham crackers pulsed into crumbs by food processor (1 cup)
  2. 6 tablespoons melted butter
  3. 2 tablespoons of brown sugar

Yogurt Pie Filling

  1. 2 cups Plain Greek Yogurt (non-fat to whole fat works for this recipe)
  2.  1 ½ Packet unflavored gelatin 
  3. 1 cup Boiling water 
  4. ⅔ cup sugar 
  5. juice and zest of 2 large limes

Making the Pie:

Graham Cracker Pie Crust

Mix together graham cracker crumbs and 1/4 cup sugar with melted butter.
  • Save
  • Mix together graham cracker crumbs with brown sugar with melted butter.
Press into 9" pie plate and Bake in preheated oven at 375 degrees for 10 minutes.
  • Save
  • Press into 9″ pie plate
  • Bake in preheated oven at 350 for 15 minutes.
  • Let crust cool completely

Key Lime Yogurt Pie Filling:

Mix gelatin with sugar and add boiling water. Stir until all sugar and gelatin is dissolved. Set aside to cool.
  • Save
  • Mix the gelatin with the sugar
  • add the boiling water and stir until all the sugar and gelatin are dissolved.
  • Set aside to cool.
Take lime zest and juice and add to gelatin mixture.
  • Save
  • Add lime zest and juice to gelatin mixture.
Blend in greek yogurt with mixer.
  • Save
  • Blend in the greek yogurt with a mixer.
Pour into baked pie crust and Refrigerate for 3 hours or until set.
  • Save
  • Pour the mixture into the baked pie crust
  • Refrigerate for 3 hours or until set.

Try some of these wonderful summertime recipes!

Check out these great products!

About Author


Hello, I am Susan and creator of I live in the beautiful state of New Hampshire. I love to cook and all that it entails, including finding that perfect recipe, gathering the ingredients, then adding my personal flare. I have many passions and cooking is one of them. I also enjoy hiking, biking, trail running and travel but most of all spending time with my family and friends in that all time favorite place to gather, the kitchen. Preparing food for the ones I love is pure joy!


  1. […] Key Lime Pie with a Twist […]

  2. Jenna L says:

    Fantastic recipe! Super easy to make and super delicious! definitely a hit at our house!

  3. […] Key Lime Pie with a Twist (Greek Yogurt) […]

I love to hear from my readers. If you liked a recipe that you found here, please let me know.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Share via
Copy link
Powered by Social Snap